Writing Workshop: Creating writing plans

Most of my sixth graders struggle with launching their ideas from notebook into longer writing pieces.  And yet, many of the ideas in their writing lists and heart maps are things they would like to transform into longer pieces for their writing portfolios. When I first began teaching Writing Workshop, I let my kids choose their own planning tools – our mini lessons covered webbings, and timelines and any b-m-e charts, and then I left it to each student to pick a tool that worked best for them.  Sometimes this worked, sometimes it did not – and we usually discovered problems halfway through the drafting process when the student was stuck: where  should I go next? what should I include? something is missing, but I don’t know what.  At this point, there were many writing conferences and I left each feeling that something had gone wrong in the writing process and we should have fixed whatever it was long before the drafting even began.
 Obviously, I needed to go back to the planning stages and figure out a better way to plan, to create a framework to guide the writing.  Now, every student must create a three-part “plan of action” in their writer’s notebook before they can begin drafting on their yellow writing pads:
  • they must choose three ideas from their writing lists for every genre piece we do (we’re working on memoir now) and create purpose statements for each: “I am writing about _________________,because I want my reader to know___________________.  I feel these statements really force my kids to focus on their topic and ensure that there is a point to this writing piece – it’s not random, they are clear about the “so what?”  This purpose statement serves as our anchor as we confer as well, which helps me guide my students through their drafting/revising stages.  
  • They must create a timeline of events – sometimes this can be detailed, and sometimes not (as in the example below – Eric’s notebook), but this timeline also serves as an anchor and a tool for me to offer advice in our conferences.  In Eric’s case, for instance, we conferred about the timeline itself – he needed many more specifics in order to be sure he knew where he was going with this piece.  Once he’d done that, he was ready to move on to the next stage.
  • Using the timeline, each student also charts a beginning-middle-end sketch: three columns (b,m,e) with specifics from their timelines sketched out in the appropriate column.  

We meet again to confer and make sure that all questions are clarified and that the student is really ready to begin drafting…and then they’re off!

All this pre-writing work lays the groundwork for a more independent drafting process.  We still meet to confer everyday, but both the student and I are so anchored in the “so what?” of their piece due to all that planning work, that the conference is more about improving the writing from a technical and emotional point of view that what it used to be:” I’m stuck, I don’t know where to go next!”
Last week, after working on these plans every day, I am happy to say that each of my kids left workshop feeling armed and ready to begin drafting tomorrow, Monday. Hooray!


3 thoughts on “Writing Workshop: Creating writing plans

  1. Isn't it amazing how much guidance our students need to lift their ideas out of their writer's notebook. Every year, I hope my students come to me with a little more knowledge of a writer's notebook and how much it will help them in their writer's life. Your scaffolding ideas are perfect and I plan to "borrow" many of them.

  2. This seems as if you are scaffolding just right, Tara. It's surprising to me even after all these years of teaching how I still make assumptions about what the students know how to do, or how to proceed, as you described. Having a plan of action seems just right. Are there possibilities of changing the plan & do you do that within the individual conferences? How about differentiation? Does everyone have success with this, or do you adapt sometimes because of a learning difference, etc.? Thanks for telling about it all the way through. This is helpful to me for working with my teachers.

  3. The plan is always there for tweaking – that's what conferences are for. But I find that all the thinking that goes into creating the plan helps sort out ideas and encourage focus. This is especially good, I find,for differentiation. My special needs kids benefit the most (Eric is one of these), it makes the task more concrete. And I find that my higher kids tend to be more elaborate in their details and time shifts – so it works both ways.

Thank you for reading my blog! Please leave a comment and share your thoughts.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s